Facts: Mother and Father divorced in 2020 and initially shared equal parenting time with their two children. Father was on active military duty, earning $5,456.79 per month, and was ordered to pay $991 per month in child support. The trial court also entered a $2,278.66 judgment for temporary-support arrears and Mother’s attorney’s fees. Father did not consistently pay the ordered support. Soon after the divorce, Father pleaded guilty under the Uniform Code of Military Justice to attempting to commit a lewd act involving a minor. He was sentenced to 110 days in jail and separated from the military, and he later obtained civilian employment earning $14.27 per hour for 31 or 32 hours per week. Father testified that he had no advanced degree, had limited skills transferable to civilian work, and had been rejected for jobs because he lacked the required qualifications. In May 2022, Father petitioned to reduce child support because his income was substantially lower after leaving the military. Mother opposed the reduction and sought a judgment for arrears. The trial court found Father willfully underemployed and continued to treat his gross monthly income as $5,456.79 (i.e., his monthly earnings in the military), reasoning that his lower earnings resulted from his intentional criminal conduct. After adjusting other worksheet entries, such as reducing Mother’s monthly income from $3,467 to $1,491, the trial court set Father’s current support at $654 per month and entered arrearage judgments totaling $23,786.35. Neither its original orders nor a supplemental order entered after a limited appellate remand addressed whether a significant variance existed. The corresponding worksheet entries were also blank. Father appealed. On Appeal: The Court of Appeals reversed the willful-underemployment finding, vacated Father’s imputed income and the support and arrearages based on it, affirmed the rulings on Mother’s income and the arrearage time frame, and remanded for further proceedings. Tennessee law and the Child Support Guidelines require a significant variance before child support may be modified, generally a difference of at least 15% between the existing obligation and the proposed Guidelines obligation. That comparison is the threshold inquiry. The parent seeking modification must prove the variance using current evidence of both parents’ gross incomes. Income may be imputed for willful underemployment, inadequate reliable income information, or substantial non-income-producing assets. Willful underemployment is not presumed and concerns the reasonableness of occupational choices in light of the support obligation, considering employment history, education, training, ability to work, and other relevant circumstances. The parent alleging willful underemployment must prove both underemployment and the income to be imputed. The Court of Appeals held that the trial court erred by modifying support without deciding the threshold significant-variance question, treated nonoccupational misconduct as an occupational choice, and imputed Father’s former military income without the proof and findings required by the Guidelines: [W]hether a significant variance exists is the threshold question in any petition to modify child support. The trial court’s failure to address this threshold question before modifying Father’s child support obligation cannot be ignored by this Court. * * * * * If we were to adopt the trial court’s reasoning, a parent could be found willfully underemployed or unemployed based on any decision he or she made if the decision adversely affected his or her income, regardless of whether the decision concerned the parent’s employment. This broad interpretation is simply not what the Guidelines intend. While we agree with the trial court that Father’s conduct was condemnable, the Guidelines simply cannot be used to further punish Father for his crime. The trial court’s reliance on Father’s choice to engage in this criminal activity as the basis for a willful underemployment finding was improperly made. * * * * * On our review of the limited evidence, we conclude that Mother simply failed to meet her burden to prove that Father was willfully underemployed. Father’s unrebutted testimony showed that he was unable to find employment that would provide him with an income near that of his income from the military and that his job prospects were limited due to his lack of formal education and training. The Court of Appeals affirmed the calculation of Mother’s income. Mother testified about her current earnings, and Father did not claim her testimony was false. As to her earlier income, the trial court reasonably calculated $3,467 per month from a $20 hourly wage and a 40-hour workweek when neither party supplied a tax return or pay stub. The Court encouraged additional evidence about the parents’ current circumstances before calculating their incomes and deciding whether a significant variance permits modification. Reversing the existing underemployment finding did not guarantee Father a reduction or prevent a properly supported imputation of income: Although we reverse the trial court’s finding that Father was willfully underemployed due to his decision to engage in illegal activity, this conclusion does not preclude the trial court from finding that Father is willfully underemployed or unemployed due to different circumstances. Similarly, the trial court is not precluded from imputing additional income to Father if it determines that such imputation is necessary after hearing additional evidence. Thus, the Court affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded the case to the trial court for further proceedings. K.O.’s Comment: Bad conduct that causes a job loss is not automatically willful underemployment. This opinion follows Wine v. Wine, 245 S.W.3d 389, 394 (Tenn. Ct. App. 2007) in looking at occupational choices rather than every choice that reduces income. The contrasting result in Goodrich v. Goodrich shows what successful proof looks like. Even though Father there was involuntarily terminated, the finding of underemployment was affirmed because his later job search was limited, he avoided the field in which he had worked most of his adult life, and he offered no medical proof supporting his claimed inability to return. Focus your evidence on what the parent did after the income loss. Source: Brown v. Brown (Tennessee Court of Appeals, Middle Section, November 5, 2026). If you find this helpful, please share it using the buttons below.
Join 1,887 other subscribers
Criminal Conduct Does Not Establish Willful Underemployment in Clarksville, Tennessee: Brown v. Brown was last modified: November 10th, 2026 by
Categories:
