Posted by: koherston | October 24, 2016

Failure to Pay Child Support Not Willful in Waverly, TN Termination of Parental Rights Case: In re Michael B.

Facts: Father and Stepmother petitioned to terminate Mother’s parental rights to Child so Stepmother could adopt Child.

knoxville divorceThe proof showed Mother was a heroin addict. She earned money through prostitution to support her drug habit.

During the four months preceding Mother’s incarceration, the trial court found Mother earned income from prostitution and used that income to purchase heroin.

Based on these findings, the trial court found Mother willfully failed to support Child during the relevant four-month period. It also found that termination of Mother’s parental rights was in Child’s best interest. Mother’s parental rights were terminated.

Mother appealed.

On Appeal: The Court of Appeals reversed the trial court.

Mother argued that although there was evidence she was earning income by engaging in prostitution, there was no evidence regarding how much she was earning, or whether this would’ve been sufficient income to allow her to provide support for Child.

Grounds for termination of parental rights by “abandonment” may be shown when a parent has willfully failed to make reasonable payments toward the support of the child during the relevant four-month period.

The party seeking termination of parental rights must prove by clear and convincing evidence that the opposing party had the capacity to pay support but made no attempt to do so and did not have a justifiable excuse.

Tennessee courts have indicated that in addition to evidence of the parent’s income during the relevant time frame, the party seeking termination must also present evidence of the parent’s expenses during that time. Without that basic information, the court is unable to determine whether the parent had the capacity to provide support.

The Court found the proof of Mother’s income and expenses lacking:

Here, there was some evidence that Mother was employed as a prostitute at various times throughout the child’s life. In addition, Mother, without providing dates, testified as to other jobs she held over the years. No proof was introduced, however, as to Mother’s actual or approximate income during the relevant four-month period. Furthermore, the record contains no evidence of Mother’s expenses during the relevant time period from which this Court could conclude that Mother had the capacity to pay support. Under these circumstances, [Father and Stepmother] failed to present clear and convincing evidence that Mother failed to pay support despite her capacity to do so.

The trial court’s ruling as to willful failure to support was reversed. The trial court terminated Mother’s parental rights on other grounds, however, and the termination was affirmed by the Court.

K.O.’s Comment: The trial court found that during the relevant four-month period Mother “was prostituting in order to obtain money to satisfy her drug habit.” Must one show exactly how much Mother was earning and how much she was spending on heroin? This opinion suggests as much. I doubt Mother kept records. Compare this case with In re Courtney N., where the mother’s purchase of a cell phone was sufficient to show she “had money available to her, from whatever source, and decided not to pay child support without any justifiable excuse.”

In re Michael B. (Tennessee Court of Appeals, Middle Section, October 6, 2016).

Information provided by K.O. Herston: Knoxville, Tennessee Divorce and Family-Law Attorney.


Responses

  1. The trial courts generally speaking will terminate on this ground if the parent is capable of working regardless of whether there is any proof of actual income and expenses. The COA has been all over the place in some cases upholding such and, in others like this case saying not enough proof. It strikes me that one way to prove up this type of case would be to get the parent to admit that he or she could have supported the kid, even for a nominal amount and then prove that they didn’t. And yet I don’t see the State do this.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Categories

%d bloggers like this: